• LYON


Important victory for Seiko Epson Corporation in dispute for patent infringement against Conzumo Servicios Online, S.L.

8 April 2015
Wed, 04/08/2015 (All day)

Hoyng Monegier has obtained a favorable decision on behalf of the Japanese manufacturer of printers and printing accessories, Seiko Epson Corporation.

Mercantile Court no. 10 of Madrid, Spain, has issued a first instance decision declaring that the offer and sale, by the Spanish company Conzumo Servicios Online, S.L., of ink cartridges compatible with Epson’s printers, directly infringes several patents owned by Epson, and that the offer and sale of replacement ink tanks for those compatible cartridges is an act of indirect infringement of the same patents.

The decision dismisses all the defensive arguments raised by Conzumo and accepts all the petitions by Epson, including the order to cease in all the infringing acts violating Epson’s rights, to cease in the import, distribution, offer and commercialization of any ink cartridges infringing Epson’s rights, including all the specific references included in the claim, to seize and destroy any remaining infringing cartridges and ink tanks, to pay an undisclosed amount as compensation of damages, to pay the costs of the procedure, and to publish the heading and decisive part of the judgment in the two main Spanish newspapers (El País and El Mundo). The decision also contains the express declaration that Conzumo has been acting on bad faith, in light of several actions carried out during the proceedings.

Seiko Epson Corporation was represented by Jose Antonio Sanmartín.

  • HOYNG ROKH MONEGIER represents the J.R. Simplot Company in a cross-border Community design dispute against McCain Foods, relating to the shape of Simplot’s proprietary twisted French fry potato product. Simplot argued McCain’s “Rustic Twist” french fry infringed their Community design.
  • Managing IP Awards / 11 March 2019
    On Thursday 7 March, Managing IP hosted its annual EMEA IP awards ceremony, honoring the best IP achievements by in-house counsel and law firms in 2018.
  • Spanish Trademark Law Reform / 22 January 2019
    The Spanish Trademark Law Reform entered into force on January 14th.
  • HOYNG ROKH MONEGIER promotes Johan Elkenbracht to the partnership. Johan Elkenbracht is a European and Dutch patent attorney.
  • A new edition of the Mobile World Congress (MWC), the world’s most important event in the mobile communications industry, will be held in Barcelona from 26th to 28th of February, 2019. The Commercial Courts of Barcelona have issued for the fifth consecutive year the Intellectual Property Fast Action Protocol in the framework of the Mobile World Congress.