• AMSTERDAM
  • BRUSSELS
  • DÜSSELDORF
  • MADRID
  • MANNHEIM
  • MUNICH
  • PARIS

Press

New victory for HARTFORD fashion brand in Spain

17 November 2017
Fri, 11/17/2017 (All day)

HOYNG ROKH MONEGIER’s Spanish team secured another success for French clothing brand HARTFORD before the European Union Trademark (EUTM) Courts in Alicante in trademark infringement and invalidity proceedings filed against Spanish optics company DIVARO (Navarro Óptico). This litigation stemmed from DIVARO’s commercial exploitation of eyewear and frames using HARTFORD’s name and logos, as well as the registration of a Spanish trademark in class 9 identical to HARTFORD’s brand as used in the market.

Following the first instance judgment, which upheld Hartford's claims at the beginning of this year, and further to DIVARO’s appeal against that decision, the EUTM Appeals Court –the most authoritative and knowledgeable Court in Spain for trademark matters- fully endorsed our client’s position again in its judgment of 26 October 2017. By rejecting DIVARO’s appeal, it endorsed that favorable first-instance judgment on all counts, reaffirming DIVARO’s infringement of HARTFORD’s trademark rights and the partial revocation of DIVARO’s Spanish trademark for the disputed goods. Furthermore, the Court ordered DIVARO to pay the legal costs of the appeal.

The core of the dispute dealt with the similarity of the goods at stake, a prerequisite for trademark infringement/invalidity due to risk of confusion.  Following a thorough analysis of the arguments and evidence submitted at trial, the EUTM Appeals Court concluded that there is indeed that required degree of similarity between clothing products and eyewear. Agreeing with the first instance ruling, the EUTM Appeals Court observed a complementary relationship between those goods, as they share “the same usual purpose, to customize a person’s image according to fashion and one’s tastes”, not being “uncommon for glasses to be combined with articles of clothing as far as style, colors, etc.”. It further added that “the conflicting goods could also be very easily considered by the relevant public as elements of a wider range of fashion products, since it is customary for fashion brands to be used with products that are not strictly textiles, but also “dress” people, affording them the imprint they desire”. Especially relevant for the Court was the ample proof submitted by HARTFORD showing that the defendant itself advertised and offered the illicitly- trademarked eyewear, “emphasizing its condition as fashion ‘complements or accessories’”.    

This is the fourth victory for our client before the Spanish EUTM Courts in Alicante: Hartford prevailed in both the first and appeal instances in the related preliminary injunction proceedings and on the merits of the main case (now being decided on appeal). This new judgment from the EUTM Appeals Court is not final, however, and may still be appealed in before the Spanish Supreme Court which may decide to revise the case if it considers it to have cassational interest.

Álvaro Velázquez and Laura Cantero represent HARTFORD in this matter. 

  • According to the current ranking of Legal 500 Germany, HOYNG ROKH MONEGIER continues to be ranked in ‘tier 1 of German patent litigation firms' in the field of Intellectual Property: Patent Litigation. Clients particularly highlight the 'excellent knowledge of the industry' and 'targeted, practice-oriented advice’, as well as the 'high level of business sense' and 'the right leverage of experienced partners and very good associates'.
  • HOYNG ROKH MONEGIER’s Spanish team successfully represented the fashion group G-STAR RAW in European Union trade mark (EUTM) infringement litigation against the Spanish fashion retail group MANGO, for unauthorized use made in the EU of its “RAW” trademark on clothing and accessories.
  • Click here to view an article "Spain's fast track for preliminary injunction procedures" written by Madrid partner Alvaro Velazquez, commenting the Fractus SA v. Shenzhen Doke Electronic Co, rendered by the Commercial Court nr 5 of Barcelona in February 2017.
  • The Paris office of HOYNG ROKH MONEGIER is reinforcing its life sciences practice with the arrival of partner Anne Servoir. Anne Servoir started her career in the competition law department of CMS-Bureau Francis Lefebvre, where she developed a practice focused on regulatory issues in various industries ranging from telecommunications to pharmaceuticals. She later joined INTUITY, a boutique life sciences firm.
  • On 12 September 2017, the preliminary relief judge of the district court of The Hague issued an injunction against two Dutch entities of the McCain group, preventing them from the manufacture and sale of McCain’s new potato product “Rustic Twist” in the European Union.