• AMSTERDAM
  • BRUSSELS
  • DÜSSELDORF
  • MADRID
  • MANNHEIM
  • MUNICH
  • PARIS

Press

Victory for PMI - General Court orders EUIPO Board of Appeals to rule again

5 February 2018
Mon, 02/05/2018 (All day)

On 1 February 2018, the General Court rendered a judgment in case T-105/16 cancelling a decision by the EUIPO’s Board of Appeals in invalidity proceedings initiated by Philip Morris (hereinafter, PMI), and ordering the Board of the EUIPO to rule again on the conflict. The Court ordered the Board to take into full account the probative value of the evidence that the latter had previously disregarded with the argument that it had been submitted for the first time during appeal proceedings and was consequently inadmissible. The Court ruled that article 76 EUTMR and Rule 50(2) EUTMIR do not allow for late evidence when it is not supplementary, but admitted the appeal based on the application of general principles of the law and, in particular, sound administration. The Court considered that there were sufficient grounds for an exception to the applicable legal provisions of the EUTMR and the EUTMIR in this case. The EUIPO and the intervener were ordered to bear the costs. This decision is welcome news after lengthy proceedings that began several years ago.

Laura Alonso and Alicia Martín of the Madrid office have represented Philip Morris since the filing of the appeal before the EUIPO Board of Appeals and before the General Court.
The judgment can be found here: http://bit.ly/2DZGjFk

  • As was two years ago in 2016, HOYNG ROKH MONEGIER Düsseldorf has been nominated as "Law Firm of the Year for IP" by industry publication JUVE. 2016 the firm has been awarded as "Law Firm of the Year for IP".
  • Fabienne Brison is pleased to announce the publication of the 4th edition of "Huldeboek/Hommage à Jan Corbet: Het Belgische auteursrecht. Artikelsgewijze commentaar / Le droit d'auteur belge. Commentaire par article", published by Larcier.
  • The Spanish Patent Act / 8 June 2018
    Luis Fernández-Novoa Valladares from our Madrid office recently published an article on the new Spanish Patent Act in the Journal of Intellectual Property Law & Practice (JIPLP) and an article about damages which was published in Spanish in the January-April edition of the “Comunicaciones en Propiedad Industrial y Derecho de la Competencia”.
  • HOYNG ROKH MONEGIER has been shortlisted by Legal Media Group for the forthcoming Europe Women in Business Law Awards.
  • Women in IP / 19 April 2018
    On April 19th, HOYNG ROKH MONEGIER proudly sponsored and co-organized the Benelux edition of the Women in IP Global Networking Event 2018.